This might fly in the face of a lot of people, but it's the complaint that there's a lack of clarity in how RPs are judged.

There is no rubric. In my experience, it's handled by a panel, not just one person, and generally it's unanimously agreed upon. As soon as there is a rubric, a few things will happen.

1. Writing quality drops to shit since everybody writes to the rubric

2. Massive bitch sessions from people who wrote to the rubric just as well as their opponent but didn't write as well as their opponent

3. Assholes like me who will DECIDEDLY write against the rubric and be seen as a spammer for telling stories within an eFed because we are no good punks who hate conformity and the imposed authority of the rubric.

That said;

I feel if we are covering every type of eFedding niche we possibly can in the XWF, perhaps it's up to the discression of those above me to establish a rubric for a show to see what works and what doesn't, but I wouldn't do it myself so there's that.