To kind of further elaborate on the judgement transparency thing, Robbie's response really hit it on the head. Like Lane said we do have a rubric, all the things RL mentioned are on there as are some others. But ultimately the reason we haven't made it public isn't because we don't want you to know it it's because we don't want you writing FOR THE RUBRIC. We want you writing what you want.(within the rules of course) This is supposed to be fun and entertaining and if you all feel like you have to write to try and check off all these boxes etc the work will suffer.

If you ever want feedback on a specific piece or your work for a rp period you can always ask the GM's and we will provide it for you. If you want some real general tips it's this:

We want to see roleplays that develop your character, typically done through story but not always. We want to see you address your opponent and we want to walk away from the roleplay knowing that your character works for a wrestling company. That's really it. Obviously there are other things we look at and how well you do those things matter but if you hit those notes you are going to do well.