I gotta go with Mister Mystery... I mean Jason Voorhees. While Myers is a hell of a killing machine, he's not as maniacal as Jason Voorhees. Jason's brute strength along with his stealth make it a mismatch. Myers can't touch Jason's strength while he could rival his stealth.

Plus, Jason has been killed like 12 times and just keeps coming back. I have to say, Kane Hodder was a good Jason and one big issue with Freddy vs Jason was that it was not Hodder. That and the special effects team was terrible. The blood spray was one thing, but when you can tell exactly where the "jets" were that sprayed the blood, you have a definite issue. That director is a shit bag.

Derek Mears in the 13 remake was pretty good. I liked the fact that they made him human rather than zombie and he used speed as well as stealth and brute strength really made him a force. The revelation of a tunnel system beneath the grounds of Crystal Lake kind of made things seem more logical as far as his ability to move around the place gave it more believable that he could be in one place, the dumb broad turns and runs the other way just for him to turn up right back in front of her.

Just an observation.