If I were to shelf one of these characters to focus on the other, vote which one...
Please write some feedback if you don't mind explaining why you think the other should be shelved

I like both characters, but I think Muddy has more possibilities and is more unique in the fed. I think Dylan is limited in the scope of what you can do with him.

From what I've seen, Muddy is pretty entertaining. And like Vinnie said, you're gonna have greater freedom with him than you will with Dylan.

1X - GOAT.

Real talk. I had a conversation about you with Kirk. We were both in agreement that Muddy Waters was far more entertaining than Dylan George. You seem to have more range and there's a bit of humor to Muddy Waters. Dylan George on the other hand, that character, and characters of that kind, they've already been done to death.

As Paulie said, it's been done to death. Not that it can't be reinvigorated and fresh, but it'll be harder to be. This is coming from someone who had a character very similar. Muddy is a more original character (oddly enough) and is quite funny.

Yeah I started hitting walls with trash talking as Dylan.

I felt like Muddy would give me a lot more creative flexability- that was the reason I created him to begins with. Thanks for the input guys

Personally bro, i'd see you more as Muddy individual than a Dylan Murderer. If you can turn around the whole "i'mma kill you and burn the bitch down" like antics with Dylan, then maybe there is a possibility of opening up boarders for a already done to death gimmick in that nature like everyone one else puts it.

So, Muddy Waters will suit you best in XWF, in fact I could actually would love to work with.