This doesn't have to be as big of a deal as you guys are making it out to be.

It's an open title/award. If you want to vote someone in because they won 12 matches in September, do it. If you want to vote someone in because they lost 12 matches in September, do it. If you want to vote someone who did two RPs for the whole month, then do it.

Just be sure to explain your reasons when you cast your vote or we may or may not take it into consideration.

There isn't a strict criteria here that we're enforcing.

It's just a way to recognize someone who stood out in the fed for the month...

Not everyone's vote needs to be the same. Not everyone's reasons/criteria need to be the same.

Personally, I look at activity (RPing, segments, and IC areas), participation (are they getting booked and showing up) and accomplishments (any big wins?).

*EDIT: ^That doesn't mean that you guys have to follow the same guidelines. It's up to you how you vote.