I had no idea the active roster was this big! It will be hard to rate everyone, so this will be pretty inaccurate.

The (?) means I haven't read much work from them, so I am in doubt.
Red for those over 80, just to make it easier to read

"The Phantom" Jack Kronus: 68
3 x Better Sid Feder: 85
Ace: 54 (?)
Adam Rollins: 59
Adrian Southall: 52 (?)
Agent Orange: 74
Agony: 50 (?)
AJ Powell: 64
Alex Richards: 52 (?)
Alex Shawn: 74
Alexandra Callaway: 82
Andrew Aldway: 70
Andrew Morrison: 74
Ann Thraxx: 78 (?)
Anthony Carter: 58 (?)
Asmodeus: 75 (?)
Baalberith: 55 (?)
Brian Braxton: 65 (?)
Caliban: 67 (?)
Casey Jones: 52 (?)
Chase A. Watson: 50 (?)
Chessmaster: 69
Chris Legend: 63
Christine Nash: 74
CM Punk: 79
Crimson Cobra: 78
Crimson Dong: 82
Danny Devia: 54 (?)
Dark Cloud: 50 (?)
David Skulley: 65 (?)
Dean Moxley McGovern: 80
Death Merchant: 72
Dominic: 51 (?)
Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson: 86
Dwight Howard: 56 (?)
El Rey: 50 (?)
Eli James IV: 87
Elisha: 81
Gamegenie: 71 (?)
Giovanni Ferrari: 75
Griffin MacAlister: 80
Guy Toadie: 66 (?)
Harold Davis: 59 (?)
Heironeous: 68 (?)
Hickster: 50 (?)
Hunter Moore: 65
Hunter Payne: 74
I - Evertrust: 79
IcePik: 50 (?)
Jack Killborn: 68
Jake Willis: 67 (?)
James Saxon: 56 (?)
Jason E Smith: 76
Jessie Diaz: 78
Joe Tuesday: 70 (?)
Joey K: 52 (?)
John Austin: 83
Johnny Xtreme: 56 (?)
John Black: 74
John/Juan/Mr.Madison: 96
Jonny Rebel: 67
JTC: 70
KidAnt: 64
Kinwrathi: 74
Knightmask: 81
LeBron James: 50 (?)
Lightning: 72
IjTheSavior: 57 (?)
Lord Malichi: 55 (?)
Luca Arzegotti: 91
Mark Flynn: 83 (?)
Matt Ward: 67
Matt Lennox: 68
Michael James: 50 (?)
Michelle Cross: 65 (?)
Mister Satty-Lite: 94
Mr. Radio: 81
Mr. Natural: 71
Mystica: 79
Neil Capra: 75 (?)
Nemo: 50 (?)
Neonero: 88
Nightmare: 83
Nollid Hawkins: 51 (?)
Peter F'n Gilmour: 83
Peter Lake: 69 (?)
Poppa Feder 17 31707 1: 82
Reaper: 66 (?)
Ricky Desmond: 80
Russell Mania: 76
Salman Van Dam 007: 71
Salvator: 70
Samantha Prater: 57 (?)
SATAN!?: 50 (?)
Scott Charlotte: 74
Sean Falcon: 73
Sebastian Duke: 95
Shawn Steele: 69
Shawn Hero: 68 (?)
Shocker: 78
Sincere Lee Wild: 68 (?)
Slickster: 68 (?)
SokolovxxRed: 50 (?)
Steve Sayors?: 5
Steve Davids: 79
Steve Fitch: 58 (?)
Stevie Tyler: 78
Sweet Cheapshots: 79 (?)
Swift Ion: 60
Table: 72
The Lionheart: 56 (?)
The Messenger?: 79
The XXX Listers: 50 (?)
The Phoenix: 54 (?)
Tim Findlay: 52 (?)
Tony Santos: 80
Troy Turner: 59 (?)
Tyler Decker: 56 (?)
Tyrone?: 81
Ultimate Mystery: 70 (?)
Unknown Soldier: 88
Ursula Areano: 71 (?)
Veda Scott: 58 (?)
Viscera: 56 (?)
Waldo: 52 (?)
White Lion: 73
World1International: 75 (?)
Wrestler82: 69
X Raided: 62 (?)