I agree and what I'm trying to shoot for is my own little version of all the best worlds...

I want to be able to tell the person the direction I want them to go in, or give them some sort of angle idea that is supposed to happen soon, and see how well THEY play it out because that in itself will be part of what then decides how strong they are in their matches, etc... If I want Drew Archyle to go full homosexual, it's up to HIM to decide what sways him toward the cock and which men he sleeps with, etc... (the stuff I suggest won't all be stupid and gay; I actually want it to be a serious show with only some sections having humor/crazy shit for an even balance)

This will combine some aspects of:
RP based feds
Angle based feds
Match writing feds (where both people write their own version of the match and the one who wrote the better match ends up winning, and the other person's work usually gets thrown out)

RPing will still weigh in heavily, but in my mind RPing will now consist of: Promos, match spots, and other segments/story I ask for to put in results. Since I'd have an idea of what I want to happen, I could tell James Raven what I expect out of his match spot to some degree, and I'll know to tell Famine of the Vile something entirely different for his spot in that same match, and I'll mold them all together and fill in the blanks. Everybody's creativity gets used, plus some added material from staff that nobody saw coming.

If I can get things to all flow together and get some good peeps to play along, it will be something that (as far as I know in all my parenthesis) is virtually unseen in any fed. Much more like a fluid TV show with intertwining, semi-planned action all along the way. Some of the episodes might not even have "matches" how we're all used to, but will still see huge developments and people getting over on other people based on their strength that week. Sometimes we won't even be in an arena at all for most of or all of an episode.