Please Log-in or Register to get full access to the forums.

Lost Password?
Current XWF board time: 12-12-2018, 08:48 PM (time should display as Pacific time zone; please contact Admin if it appears to be wrong)                                                                
X-treme Wrestling Federation BOARDS » XWF OOC » Out Of Character (OOC) Board
Post Reply 
 
Thread Rating:
  • 0 Votes - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Anybody? lol
Author Message
 Shane Carver  Offline
The Disassembler



XWF FanBase:
Hardcore, psycho fans

(cheered for breaking rules and bones; excessively violent; creative with weapons)


Post: #1
03-11-2018 10:15 PM

Ok so after some talks and hearing some feedback, I just have to reach out and see who here is actually a current wrestling fan AND is able to wrap their mind around the prospect of real wrestlers being used in an e-fed and being able to interact with the vast majority of created characters?

For those of you who are opposed to such ideas, are you willing to share explanations as to why? And are you open minded enough to hear the responses that address those concerns and put them to rest, or are you dead set in your ways?

All comments and feedback welcome in either direction!

 
[Image: X3tQQiM.jpg]
I'm Shane Carver under this mask, I promise -told you so


Ever curious what people are up to?

Find
Edit Reply Quote
"Dark Warrior" Micheal Graves
Unregistered



XWF FanBase:
(.Awaiting user update)


Post: #2
03-11-2018 10:25 PM

We don't stifle creativity.

Imo that includes real / dead wrestlers being allowed.
Reply Quote
Peter Fn Gilmour Offline
RULER AND GOD OF XTREME MEN!



XWF FanBase:
(.Awaiting user update)


Post: #3
03-12-2018 01:25 AM

get adam cole and kevin steen here NOW!

[Image: h7hb52C.png]

[Image: JeeZbnb.gif]

SUCK... MY... DICK!

3X Star of the Month
Former 3x Hart Champion
Former 13X Xtreme Champion
Former 5X Tag Champion
Former 2X Trios Champion
Former 2x Heavy Metal Weight Champion
Former Universal Champion
Find
Reply Quote
 Shane Carver  Offline
The Disassembler



XWF FanBase:
Hardcore, psycho fans

(cheered for breaking rules and bones; excessively violent; creative with weapons)


Post: #4
03-12-2018 01:48 AM

I'd mark out if they showed up on warfare and attacked you

 
[Image: X3tQQiM.jpg]
I'm Shane Carver under this mask, I promise -told you so


Ever curious what people are up to?

Find
Reply Quote
Cadryn Leslie Tiberius
Unregistered



XWF FanBase:
(.Awaiting user update)


Post: #5
03-12-2018 01:58 AM

I'm with Graves.

We pride ourselves on being the most open minded fed out there.

Plus I think it would add a whole new element to our shows to see something like

"Engy and The Rock vs Apex"

It would be fun to see how some of these guys are able to portray big names like that, etc.
Reply Quote
Chris Valley Offline
Registered but either hasn't added self to a roster yet or doesn't RP



XWF FanBase:
Hardcore, psycho fans

(cheered for breaking rules and bones; excessively violent; creative with weapons)


Post: #6
03-12-2018 02:02 AM

I'm use too playing real wrestlers. Truth be told this is my first fed experience with a CAW. I think it'd be neat, but I feel newbies would come in and start breaking the fourth wall and making up their own lore and giving themselves all these achivements rather than start fresh.

[Image: 1506962071215.gif]

WARFARE'S MAD DOG VALLEY
Find
Reply Quote
The Engineer
Unregistered



XWF FanBase:
(.Awaiting user update)


Post: #7
03-12-2018 04:48 AM

I'm not a huge fan of it, but I won't stand in the way of it either. My biggest question though is will that character's past history be intact then? For example if Austin gets booked is everything he's done throughout his career considered to have happened? How does that work for people who are actually dead then?
Reply Quote
Hollywood Hulk Hogan Offline
nWo 4 Life Brother!



XWF FanBase:
Men, some teens

(booed by casual fans; opportunistic; often plays dirty)


Post: #8
03-12-2018 06:15 AM

Well let me tell you something brother!!!

What was I saying?

[Image: ICEfL.jpg]

n.W.o
4 Life Brother


Find
Reply Quote
Sting Offline
Registered but either hasn't added self to a roster yet or doesn't RP



XWF FanBase:
Kids, disabled people, casual fans

(fighting the odds; helps others; disliked by most adult male fans)


Post: #9
03-12-2018 06:29 AM

Hogan! You’re a coward!
Find
Reply Quote
Vincent Lane
Unregistered



XWF FanBase:
(.Awaiting user update)


Post: #10
03-12-2018 06:36 AM

I'm not against allowing it, but I'm not a huge fan of it personally. I think some people can really nail the characters and it's fun and amusing, but there's not a lot creatively there. To me, if you're going to write original stories with existing characters, why not just make up the character too?

Then again, I'm not really into fan fiction or extended universe novels either, so it may just be me.
Reply Quote
Robbie Bourbon Offline
Man of the People



XWF FanBase:
Very random

(heel alignment but liked by many; has earned respect despite breaking the rules often)


Post: #11
03-12-2018 07:40 AM

I think it's fine so long as the player understands they are incorporating their favorite wrestler/persona into the XWF, and that strange things can happen to them, and that the XWF isn't designed to change automatically because someone decided to play Vince McMahon and that IRL such-and-such would actually happen. If the player gets upset that 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin gets put through a table because IRL Stone Cold just shows up and gives people stunners, or unhappy that John Cena loses match after match even though IRL he doesn't necessarily, there could be a problem.

[Image: 5uxLJcp.gif]
Fuck Off.

Hart Champion - January 18, 2017 - April 1, 2017
XWF Universal Champion - September 17,
2017 - January 17, 2018
Find
Reply Quote
"Dark Warrior" Micheal Graves
Unregistered



XWF FanBase:
(.Awaiting user update)


Post: #12
03-12-2018 07:41 AM

It's not just you. I shudder everytime I see a Steve Austin and a Macho Man, but I'm all for letting people do what they want.

So to expand on what I said earlier, I don't like it personally, but I'm not against it.

I'll probably regret that statement if we end up with a WWE lite roster though lol
Reply Quote
John Cena 2099 Offline
The Champ is HERE!



XWF FanBase:
Kids, women, some teens

(fighting the odds; helps others; disliked by adult males)


Post: #13
03-12-2018 08:15 AM

Just then...


[Image: giphy.gif]
[Image: dKlUwX.gif]


JOHN CENA 2099 ARRIVES FROM THE FUTURE!!!! OH MY GOD HE'S AA-ING EVERYONE!!!!


"YO DAWG I heard you said my name! But if you ain't got the BALLS to man up and prove you got what it takes to beat the Face that Runs the Place and also Lives in Outer Space, then I guess you just a BITCH!"

Half the crowd boos while half cheers. Some people starting singing John Cena Suuuuuucks" to the tune of his theme music, which was number one on the Billboard charts for an unprecedented span running from 2035-2080.

"Hey, some of y'all love me, and some of y'all hate me... and that's okay! Y'all paid your tickets. As long as I get my road to Wrestlemania!"

Cena 2099 points to the Wrestlemania sign that you didn't know was here until just now because it actually follows him wherever he goes.


[Image: cena2.jpg]
Find
Reply Quote
Muddy Waters Offline
Registered but either hasn't added self to a roster yet or doesn't RP



XWF FanBase:
(.Awaiting user update)


Post: #14
03-12-2018 11:33 AM

I think it's a fantastic idea and would be ready and willing to participate.

[Image: qyu9uw.gif]

(3X) Federweight Champion
Find
Reply Quote
The Macho Man Randy Savage Offline
Ooooh Yeeah, nWo, DIGGIT!



XWF FanBase:
Very random

(heel alignment but liked by many; has earned respect despite breaking the rules often)


Post: #15
03-12-2018 11:43 AM

Suck my dick!

[Image: aiV8fLy.jpg]
Find
Reply Quote
Peter Fn Gilmour Offline
RULER AND GOD OF XTREME MEN!



XWF FanBase:
(.Awaiting user update)


Post: #16
03-12-2018 01:51 PM

(03-12-2018 01:48 AM)Shane Carver Said:  I'd mark out if they showed up on warfare and attacked you

you forget I told both of them personally that I use their characters in a fictional wrestling fed called XWF and they laughed and said it was awesome.. go back to sniffing potatoes old man

[Image: h7hb52C.png]

[Image: JeeZbnb.gif]

SUCK... MY... DICK!

3X Star of the Month
Former 3x Hart Champion
Former 13X Xtreme Champion
Former 5X Tag Champion
Former 2X Trios Champion
Former 2x Heavy Metal Weight Champion
Former Universal Champion
Find
Reply Quote
Finn Kühn
Unregistered



XWF FanBase:
(.Awaiting user update)


Post: #17
03-12-2018 01:57 PM

no u
Reply Quote
The Engineer
Unregistered



XWF FanBase:
(.Awaiting user update)


Post: #18
03-12-2018 04:01 PM

(03-12-2018 07:40 AM)Robbie Bourbon Said:  I think it's fine so long as the player understands they are incorporating their favorite wrestler/persona into the XWF, and that strange things can happen to them, and that the XWF isn't designed to change automatically because someone decided to play Vince McMahon and that IRL such-and-such would actually happen. If the player gets upset that 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin gets put through a table because IRL Stone Cold just shows up and gives people stunners, or unhappy that John Cena loses match after match even though IRL he doesn't necessarily, there could be a problem.

This is a really salient point too. I've always found incorporating real life characters in to be tough on a number of levels. I mean, we're talking real life bankable stars who may end up jobbing to people's CAW's and that could be hard to swallow.

If you're willing to think outside the box enough though there could be workarounds. I once played a character in another fed who was a crazy person but was convinced he was Blackjack Mulligan right down to his music, promos, thinking he was still wrestling in the Deep South Territories in the 70's, not understanding modern technology, and thought his psychiatrist was Bobby Heenan. He was, for all intents and purposes, Blackjack...but not.
Reply Quote
The Engineer
Unregistered



XWF FanBase:
(.Awaiting user update)


Post: #19
03-12-2018 04:06 PM

Goddammit if I didn't just laugh at that Stone Cold promo though....
Reply Quote
Jeremiahdixon Offline
Registered but either hasn't added self to a roster yet or doesn't RP



XWF FanBase:
Some of everyone

(cheered; very rarely plays dirty but isn't lame either; many likable qualities)


Post: #20
03-12-2018 07:20 PM

I think if your that big of a fan that you want to portray a Hogan, Savage, Rock, Cena, etc, just change the name. But we all should police it and make sure the ideas are new and not just rewriting a history book, that ruins the brainstorm and creativity of those of us who brainstorm actual stories to write about.

[Image: JQ0zJTP.jpg?2]
Find
Reply Quote
Peter Fn Gilmour Offline
RULER AND GOD OF XTREME MEN!



XWF FanBase:
(.Awaiting user update)


Post: #22
03-13-2018 12:45 AM

(03-12-2018 01:57 PM)Finn Kühn Said:  no u

uh i sniff pussy sir

[Image: h7hb52C.png]

[Image: JeeZbnb.gif]

SUCK... MY... DICK!

3X Star of the Month
Former 3x Hart Champion
Former 13X Xtreme Champion
Former 5X Tag Champion
Former 2X Trios Champion
Former 2x Heavy Metal Weight Champion
Former Universal Champion
Find
Reply Quote
Imperial
Unregistered



XWF FanBase:
(.Awaiting user update)


Post: #23
03-15-2018 12:19 AM

Personally, I disagree with it. Simply because half the fun of playing a real-life wrestler is their backstory, mannerisms and the entire lore surrounding that character. This, when applied to a fed with a mixture of the two, really makes it hard to reconcile. It would make little sense for a fresh wrestler to match up against The Rock for instance.

It would also hurt my soul to see a The Rock lose trash-talk battles.

However, I do think exceptions can be made in that it requires GM/Admin permission before a real-life wrestler is allowed. This would guarantee that the handler handling him is known to be responsible, and has the ability to use the wrestler of his choice. I don't think we should do any policing as a fed, but the admins regulating it makes sense to me.
Reply Quote
Vincent Lane
Unregistered



XWF FanBase:
(.Awaiting user update)


Post: #24
03-15-2018 06:55 AM

There HAVE been some really fun takes on real wrestler feds. I know a while back John Samuels was in a fed as Ric Flair, and the shit he wrote as Naitch was fucking hilarious.
Reply Quote
Z Offline
Registered but either hasn't added self to a roster yet or doesn't RP



XWF FanBase:
Mixed reactions

(cheered heavily at home; hated by some; dips between clean/dirty)


Post: #25
03-15-2018 07:06 AM

Maybe give it a test run or their own division or show to be sure they are not put into certain situations. I just don't see guys like the Rock, Cena, and Undertaker competing in scat matches. It all depends on the situation though. Would love to see a Voodoo Lumberjack match between Z and Taker though.

[Image: 2015-06-11-Wrestling2076.jpg]

Z LIVES
Find
Reply Quote
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)