My vote goes to Gator.

My alliance with him aside, this guy has been incredibly consistent week in and week out. TV Title defenses, Winning the Uni title from Morbid only to lose it via a cash in, and has done loads of work behind the scenes with banners and other duties. Lane and Doc have put out great content, but at least for my criteria, Gator stands out head and shoulders above the rest. His roleplays are right up there with the funniest and most entertaining I have read. Untouchable in Feb.