I do believe that those individuals who commit to The Black Circle do become eternal.

Otherwise...

How do you explain me being able to defeat 30 of the best wrestlers in the world at Gauntlet City after being attacked by a branding iron, a staple gun, and a satanic fire ball?

How else would you explain the fact that this crown doesn't seem to leave my head?

How else would you explain me being able to lead Luca Arzegotti to the main event of Leap of Faith?

And finally, just take a look at what I accomplished with Eli James IV in such a short amount of time. In less than 30 days, he was able to capture two pieces of gold while under the influence of The Black Circle.

Even Sebastian Duke was able to claim gold thanks to The Black Circle's leadership (that's me, by the way).

Now, what evidence do you have to support the notion that The Black Circle isn't eternal?

You've been here a long time, Griffin, and what have you accomplished? You should have taken my offer to become eternal along with Luca and Eli!

WE won that six man tag team match together against Joseph Page in 2012.

WE won the War Games match in 2012 after I selected you to fight for me.

What has Duke ever done for you?