+- X-treme Wrestling Federation (https://xwf99.com)
+-- Forum: XWF OOC (https://xwf99.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=15)
+--- Forum: Out Of Character (OOC) Board (https://xwf99.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=29)
+--- Thread: Top 50 question (/showthread.php?tid=40024)
Top 50 question - Centurion - 03-05-2021
First of all, great idea taking the names of the Hall of Legends out of the list. I think that makes the most sense.
Question regarding Number 41 - Maverick. Is that the newer Maverick, the same one played by Finn Kunn? Or is that the old school Wildcard Maverick?
Top 50 question - R.L. Edgar - 03-05-2021
I think that’s Finn, could be wrong.
re:Top 50 question - "Loverboy" Vinnie Lane - 03-05-2021
It is Finn. I don't really know the old one, but I think he's in the Hall, right? Or am I wrong there?
Top 50 question - HeavensToBetsy - 03-05-2021
I just wanted to add that it warms my heart to see Dan Fierce in there.
Top 50 question - Ash Quinn - 03-05-2021
I think having names that haven't done anything since the dawn of time is wrong. I feel that's what the Hall is for. How was the Top 50 determined because I think folks like Charlie Nickles and Jenny Myst should be in there if people like Miss Fury and some others are there. Thad wasn't listed, Doc, Chris Page so many current guys honestly. All in all, it was very cool to see a compact history of the fed though.
re:Top 50 question - Mr. Oz - 03-05-2021
Goddammit, Lane.
re:Top 50 question - B.O.B. D - 03-05-2021
(03-05-2021, 11:54 AM)Ash Quinn Said: I think having names that haven't done anything since the dawn of time is wrong. I feel that's what the Hall is for. How was the Top 50 determined because I think folks like Charlie Nickles and Jenny Myst should be in there if people like Miss Fury and some others are there. Thad wasn't listed, Doc, Chris Page so many current guys honestly. All in all, it was very cool to see a compact history of the fed though.
Well, considering Chaos IS Myst, that's a moot point. Thad is in the Hall as Sebastian I believe, as is Page and Doc(at least I THINK).
As for people on the list that aren't active, eventually they'll get in the Hall and move off the list.
re:Top 50 question - Corey Smith - 03-05-2021
(03-05-2021, 11:54 AM)Ash Quinn Said: I think having names that haven't done anything since the dawn of time is wrong. I feel that's what the Hall is for. How was the Top 50 determined because I think folks like Charlie Nickles and Jenny Myst should be in there if people like Miss Fury and some others are there. Thad wasn't listed, Doc, Chris Page so many current guys honestly. All in all, it was very cool to see a compact history of the fed though.
People like Doc, Duke, and Page are not listed because they're in the Hall of Fame, which is considered it's own accolade for people who have been around a while and achieved a lot.
Edit: Beaten like a big swollen D
re:Top 50 question - Doctor Louis D'Ville - 03-05-2021
(03-05-2021, 11:54 AM)Ash Quinn Said: I think having names that haven't done anything since the dawn of time is wrong. I feel that's what the Hall is for. How was the Top 50 determined because I think folks like Charlie Nickles and Jenny Myst should be in there if people like Miss Fury and some others are there. Thad wasn't listed, Doc, Chris Page so many current guys honestly. All in all, it was very cool to see a compact history of the fed though.
Someone didnt read Vinnie's post....
re:Top 50 question - "Loverboy" Vinnie Lane - 03-05-2021
Charlie is a guy who will almost certainly be on there in future iterations, as will folks like Ruby or Kenzi Grey or Lycana etc etc etc. But, Charlie has only been here for like 7-8 months? I definitely looked at people who were here for less than a year as pretty much not-yet-qualified.
As for older names, some of them actually never received the recognition that they deserved for one reason or another. Sure, they may just sit there forever or get bumped up or down, but their contributions deserve to be remembered in some way. This list is literally spanning the entire fed's history, with input from people who were here before I ever was taken into account.
re:Top 50 question - Mr. Oz - 03-05-2021
Justin Sane was here longer than a year? I thought he was around for like, 4 months, max.
re:Top 50 question - ALIAS - 03-05-2021
(03-05-2021, 11:15 AM)HeavensToBetsy Said: I just wanted to add that it warms my heart to see Dan Fierce in there.
Killjoy too. And Alex Cutwright. Loved those guys.
For future consideration (unless I missed them): Hunter Ryan and former Universal Champion Jon Page.
re:Top 50 question - "Loverboy" Vinnie Lane - 03-05-2021
I don't actually know how long his run was, but I should clarify I am talking about in terms of recency. Like - no one should be considered among the "all time" of anything within their first year of joining.
(03-05-2021, 12:42 PM)Money Oswald Said: Justin Sane was here longer than a year? I thought he was around for like, 4 months, max.
re:Top 50 question - "Loverboy" Vinnie Lane - 03-05-2021
Which one is Jon Page? I see his name pop up from time to time but no one seems to really advocate for him when we have these "all time" conversations.
Additional question - how many goddamn Pages were there???
(03-05-2021, 12:57 PM)Alias Said:(03-05-2021, 11:15 AM)HeavensToBetsy Said: I just wanted to add that it warms my heart to see Dan Fierce in there.
Killjoy too. And Alex Cutwright. Loved those guys.
For future consideration (unless I missed them): Hunter Ryan and former Universal Champion Jon Page.
re:Top 50 question - ALIAS - 03-05-2021
Page had a relatively short run as a consistently active guy around 03/04 but was in the main event the entire time he was around, winning the Uni Title and X-Mas X-Treme tournament and led a stable called Fully Loaded that included the likes of myself (hence my bias here) and Psyko Stevo. He possibly had a bigger role though as the fed head of an affiliate fed so had a big role in the development of some members (similar to CCP in that sense). To the best of my knowledge he still floats around the efedding community as a whole so his name has probably come up elsewhere too, though I wouldn't be surprised if there were more than one person with that name, kinda like there being a million Justin Sane's in efedding.
re:Top 50 question - "Loverboy" Vinnie Lane - 03-05-2021
There have been at least two Justin Sane's HERE in the last 5-6 years alone! Granted one of them spelled it Sayn, but YOU GET THE IDEA!
Top 50 question - R.L. Edgar - 03-05-2021
Our Justin sane for sure deserved to be on there.
IC and two time case holder. He could have been Uni champ whenever he wanted. When I first came in that was one of the guys you looked up to
Top 50 question - Noah Jackson - 03-05-2021
Sane was my boy, miss that cunt. If he wasn't too busy railing every girl in Tasmania he would have 100% been a Uni champ at some point, incredible writer. Also not sure if this was counted in his nomination but dude did quite a lot behind the scenes here.
He also had the most beautiful blue eyes I ever did see.
Top 50 question - R.L. Edgar - 03-05-2021
Tasmanian Devil Tamer
Top 50 question - LiamRoberts - 03-05-2021
Dan Fierce what a loser
re:Top 50 question - Steve Jason - 03-05-2021
(03-05-2021, 09:25 AM)Centurion Said: First of all, great idea taking the names of the Hall of Legends out of the list. I think that makes the most sense.
Co-signed. I think it’s a good move to split legends into their own little group (and let’s be fair, you can’t really rank legends due to the myriad ways they got that way). Also I get to pretend I’m a Viking.
Good list and selection too!
re:Top 50 question - Thaddeus Duke - 03-06-2021
(03-05-2021, 03:50 PM)Noah Jackson Said: He also had the most beautiful blue eyes I ever did see.
I agree. But didn't he have like one green eye and one blue eye? I forget the term for it.
re:Top 50 question - Ash Quinn - 03-06-2021
I reread Vinnies post my bad y’all Jeez
re:Top 50 question - Michael McBride - 03-21-2021
I was just shocked I was on it and very grateful to be even talked about to be on it. So thank you all who thought I should be listed.
re:Top 50 question - "Loverboy" Vinnie Lane - 03-22-2021
With the amount of titles you have won and the contributions you've made, plus your duration - it was kind of a no-brainer.
(03-21-2021, 03:31 PM)Michael McBride Said: I was just shocked I was on it and very grateful to be even talked about to be on it. So thank you all who thought I should be listed.
re:Top 50 question - HeavensToBetsy - 03-22-2021
(03-05-2021, 04:51 PM)LiamRoberts Said: Dan Fierce what a loser
Okay, goodbye to you.
re:Top 50 question - LiamRoberts - 03-22-2021
(03-22-2021, 10:46 AM)HeavensToBetsy Said:(03-05-2021, 04:51 PM)LiamRoberts Said: Dan Fierce what a loser
Okay, goodbye to you.
But Dan is a Lunatic how could anyone like that guy?
re:Top 50 question - Charlie Nickles - 03-22-2021
(03-22-2021, 10:33 AM)"Loverboy" Vinnie Lane Said: With the amount of titles you have won and the contributions you've made, plus your duration - it was kind of a no-brainer.
(03-21-2021, 03:31 PM)Michael McBride Said: I was just shocked I was on it and very grateful to be even talked about to be on it. So thank you all who thought I should be listed.
Simp